Chapter 5. Learning When Answers Are Free
Near the end of our interview, I asked the lecturer in my study who, as Chapter 4 describes, drafted her exam with ChatGPT, what future teachers should learn. Her answer began at home.
‘Take ChatGPT as an example: my son searches for something on it, and I tell him to type it out so he can learn spelling’ (Ilyas, 2026, Participant L4).
Type it out. Three words that hold this chapter’s worry. Some effort is not a cost on the way to learning. It is the learning.
In this chapter
This chapter asks a question that every teacher now faces. How do we protect thinking when answers cost nothing?
What the chapter covers
- Doing is not learning
- What offloading costs
- What happens when students get the answer
- When the tutor holds back
- The feeling of knowing
- Access is not engagement
- Settings that hold back answers
- Homework and the check of knowing
- What to protect
- In practice
- When resources are thin
- Questions for reflection
- Framework connections
Questions for reflection
Take these questions to your next department meeting, or into a quiet moment after school.
- Where in your subject does the struggle itself do the teaching, and where is it only a barrier?
- Think of a recent homework task. What would a student lose if a chatbot did it for them?
- How would you know, without a written answer, whether a student understands work they have handed in?
- At what point in your lessons should AI help appear, before the attempt, during it or after it?
- Which of your students would not know what to ask a tutor, and how could you teach them?